Get this weeks

Engineering Trivia Challenge!!

A new set of Questions

EVERY WEEK

 

Challenge your workmates.

Find out who knows the most useless trivia. 

Login to EngCom



Save to del.ico.us Save This Page

Bring Back The Slide Rule

 
 Old fashioned, dead, gone , quaint antiquity, confined to the museum of old technologies.
Well maybe, but maybe not.
I believe that use of the slide rule should be resurrected. Not only should it be a compulsory Engineering subject but Slide Rules should be an essential “tool of trade” for Engineers in the work environment.
Why would anyone want to use a slide rule with its approximation and need to think through the units and location of the decimal point when a simple calculator will give the answer to an accuracy to six or eight or 10 decimal points?

For that very reason - “A NEED TO THINK”

 It is too easy to punch in numbers and blindly accept the electronic answer. Unfortunately, if the numbers or decimal points are entered incorrectly, the answer will obviously be incorrect. If the user has no concept of approximation and what the answer should be, they will continue on, with totally useless and in some cases devastating results.
 A case in point being the $125 million Mars orbiter which crashed in 1999 due to a mix up in units between imperial and metric.
If the Engineers had been forced to look at the data and THINK, then very likely the alarm bells would have been ringing immediately, that something didn't add up.

Whilst the slide rule is not accurate to ever increasing decimal places, it doesn't matter. How many times do we need an answer to 10 decimal places ? It's a gross overkill which just causes confusion.
Apply the KISS principle and Keep It Simple, Stupid.

                                                       

Friday 12 February, 2010 11:15 PM
 
< Prev   Next >
"A good scientist is a person with original ideas. A good engineer is a person who makes a design that works with as few original ideas as possible" - Freeman Dyson